Clashing Myths
Authors: Irene Bavuso and Guido Furlan
Published: September 25, 2026
How can history and archaeology contribute to the shaping of a new European constitutional ecology? Does it make sense to look back to a far distant past to address issues of absolute and contingent relevance to the present? And if so, what kind of (critical) gaze should we adopt towards the past? Should we expect to learn something useful (historia magistra vitae, as the old adage goes), or should we rather look back only to inevitably find ourselves again?
In Steven Spielberg’s remarkable film Amistad, Anthony Hopkins, playing John Quincy Adams, reaches the conclusion in his final argument that, ultimately, what we are is what we were. And that turning towards those who preceded us should not be regarded as a sign of weakness or as a threat to our (exacerbated) individualism, precisely because there is no break in continuity between those who preceded us and ourselves.
Then perhaps it does make sense to look back and see what we, as humanity, have done in terms of sustainability, as we tried to regulate and develop, in essence, the relationship between ourselves and the planet on which we live.
History, archaeology, and anthropology have the capacity to lift the veil of time and bring us closer to what we have been – though we should always be aware that, even if human beings may have indeed remained fundamentally the same, the material and superstructural circumstances of their existence have always been different.
Our planet aside, what we inherit are not so much identities, but ideas (good or bad). Looking back at past ideas and approaches to sustainability may not be necessarily conducive to a lost wisdom, and the questions that arise are likely to outnumber the answers. Perhaps, however, one could begin by dispelling some myths about the past of the communities that succeeded one another in Europe and about their relationship with the environment they lived in. That may at least provide a basis for attempting to more consciously design a new future – hopefully, one different from our present.
Anyone concerned with Europe and law cannot avoid engaging with the Roman world. A civilisation, a culture (two extraordinarily difficult words), and, in some respects, also a burden, made of both lights and shadows – it continues to influence our thinking in many fields.
When we speak of ancient Rome, the Roman economy, and sustainability, two historiographical and cultural myths stand out particularly clearly: that of Rome as a precursor of an industrial and almost consumerist economy, whose collapse left western Europe in ruins and decay, and that of a Roman world in which Nature is well governed by human ingenuity, which protects the territory and makes it suitable for human existence.
It is true that the exploitation of specific natural resources reached a peak of intensity in the Roman period that would not be matched in Europe for centuries. At the same time, many studies in archaeology and history have shown that practices of recycling and reuse were widespread – and important – across the Roman world: they were so pervasive that the resulting picture seems one where economic circularity was not linked to exceptional circumstances. On the contrary, it represented a common mental and material framework for individuals and communities. Until not long ago, the insurgence of phenomena of reuse of buildings and sites, the recycling of everyday materials such as metals, glass, or even pottery and textiles, were all understood as clear symptoms of declining economies and societies. Research on Roman archaeology and history has shown that circularity was not a function of economic conditions, good or bad, but represented the standard practice even for people living in periods of economic stability or growth. This has been a major turning point in our understanding of the past: the linear economic model of production, consumption, and discard, which was long privileged by the scholarship, turns out to be an oversimplification that hides what is better framed as a circular model.
This recognition is also central to the dismantling of another cultural myth – that of the medieval period as the ‘Dark Ages’, in which the fragmentation of the Roman empire would leave new societies to face ruins, economic collapse, disrupted networks, and a systematic loss of high-level technical knowledge. Economic circularity was standard practice, and ‘need’ was only one of the many possible motivations behind practices of recycling and reuse – others, very importantly, were ideology and mentality. While ideology may, for instance, involve the conscious creation of connections with the past through practices of reuse, ‘mentality’ may be used as an umbrella term: communities and individuals simply made the fullest possible use of resources – an approach that is closely connected to what we understand today as being sustainable. While many questions remain open about the significance and impact of economic circularity on past economies as a whole, research continues to illuminate how local communities interacted with their landscape in sophisticated ways, managing themselves through rules and communal activities that enabled them to better face collective challenges. Although the fragmentation of extant primary sources sometimes makes it difficult to reconstruct these stories, evidence of collective efforts to cope with shortages and adverse conditions, and more generally to manage natural resources, can be found at many different levels, ranging from wealthy ecclesiastical institutions managing their estates to local village communities.
The relationship between humans and the landscape also affects the second myth surrounding the Roman world: the extraordinary mastery with which territories were managed, not only from an economic perspective but above all in terms of what we would today define as environmental safety. This is particularly evident in the management of water and in the reduction – to use a modern term – of hydrogeological risk.
To be fair, this myth appears to hold true in most cases: field systems, artificial canals, embankments, and urban sewerage systems constructed during the Roman period still testify to the attention devoted, particularly at certain times, to these issues. Yet things did not always unfold as they were supposed to, once again following patterns that we can readily recognise in the world of today.
The recent combination of a significant range of archaeological and geoarchaeological indicators has made it possible to understand how the ancient city of Aquileia, one of the major metropolises of the ancient Mediterranean, experienced episodes of urban degradation as a result of the mismanagement of the waters surrounding the settlement. Most probably, the decision to undertake new and grandiose building projects in structurally fragile areas made a decisive contribution to the situation: the construction of new neighbourhoods involved the infilling of some watercourses, with the consequent disruption of part of the city's drainage system and the spread of episodes of rising surface water, ultimately leading to costly adaptation works in some buildings and even to the early abandonment of others.
In short, conflicting interests and bad policies resulting in episodes of poor management of urban and non-urban contexts, occurring moreover in conjunction with medium- and long-term environmental changes, are not an exclusive feature of the modern world. Identifying such episodes in our past may not help us prevent them in the future, of course. Yet if we are able to fully appreciate, from the perspective afforded by time, what important consequences these episodes had, could this, at least, contribute to the development of more informed policies?
You may cite this blog as follows (APA): Bavuso, I. and Furlan, G. (2026, September 25) Clashing Myths. https://www.uu.nl/en/research/sustainability/impact/project-gallery/sig…