New decision-making tool helps the media sector make ethical choices about AI
Utrecht University and DPG Media launch DEDA for Media
The media sector is undergoing profound change as a result of the rapid rise of AI. Newsrooms, publishers and broadcasters are therefore facing urgent questions. To help the sector make well-informed decisions, Data School at Utrecht University, in collaboration with DPG Media, is launching the free DEDA for Media decision-making tool (The Ethical Data Assistant, D4M).
AI in the Media
“Like many other sectors, the media industry is under considerable pressure to roll out AI- and data-driven solutions quickly,” says researcher Eduard Saakashvili. This raises both ethical and strategic questions. For example, how can you harness the potential of AI without losing sight of journalistic values, public responsibility and the audience’s trust? How can you bring employees on board? And how can you avoid becoming dependent on technology companies?
“When editorial decisions are outsourced to opaque systems, this carries significant risks. It may undermine the autonomy of journalists and editors, or dilute the identity of media organisations. Public outrage over a lack of authenticity is also a real possibility.”
“The ethical risks associated with data and AI systems are particularly significant in the media sector, because trust plays a crucial role here,” explains media scholar Karin van Es. She led the development of DEDA for Media. “This decision-making tool helps users identify and address risks at an early stage, before they result in harm.”
“DEDA for Media ensures that the values and mission of media organisations remain central when using AI,” says Saakashvili. “This includes informing society with independent, reliable and transparent information, as well as preserving editorial pluralism: the idea that different media outlets have a unique voice and identity.”
How does DEDA for Media work?
DEDA for Media takes the form of a poster that teams work through together, step by step. The method makes tensions between design choices, project objectives and journalistic values visible. By reflecting together on a project’s purpose, the data and technology used, and the potential consequences for audiences, newsrooms and organisations, participants can identify and mitigate risks at an early stage.
The importance of trust makes the use of AI and data in the media sector particularly risky.
The method is not a checklist with predetermined answers; instead, it encourages creative and constructive discussion. Participants jointly determine which values should guide their organisation. Rather than focusing solely on technical questions, DEDA for Media brings social, cultural and governance issues to the fore. The outcome is an overview of key points to consider and concrete actions to be taken as the project progresses.
DEDA for Media is available free of charge. Organisations can receive support from Data School, for example with moderating a DEDA for Media session or delivering a train-the-trainer programme. Data School also offers AI literacy training for the media sector, which incorporates DEDA for Media.
How was DEDA for Media developed?
A team of researchers at Data School developed DEDA for Media in collaboration with DPG Media. DEDA for Media is inspired by Data School’s DEDA method, which has been used by local authorities, government ministries and other public-sector organisations for more than a decade.
The development of DEDA for Media followed the principles of Collaborative Action Research. In this approach, researchers and professionals work together to examine practical issues while simultaneously developing improvements.
Data School used a literature review to identify relevant ethical frameworks and subsequently tested DEDA for Media in several pilot projects at DPG Media. The method was refined continuously on the basis of real-world cases. As a result, at its launch, DEDA for Media was both grounded in research and closely aligned with professional practice.
Explore DEDA for Media
DEDA for Media is freely available online. Media organisations interested in collaborating can contact Data School.